Can You Sue Someone for Attempted Insurance Fraud?

Insurance fraud generally refers to intentionally providing false information or engaging in deceptive practices to obtain insurance benefits that one is not entitled to. In many jurisdictions, it is possible to take legal action against someone for attempted insurance fraud. However, the specifics can vary depending on the laws of the country or state involved.

Definition of insurance fraud

Insurance fraud is a dishonest and illegal act that occurs when an individual or entity knowingly attempts to deceive an insurance company to obtain benefits or advantage to which they are not entitled. It can range from misrepresenting facts to deliberately causing a loss in order to collect insurance payouts. According to the law, insurance fraud can only be prosecuted when the suspect had a specific intent to defraud and an act is completed in furtherance of that intent. Insurance fraud can be committed by both policyholders and insurance providers. Instances of insurer fraud include denying legitimate claims without just cause, misrepresenting policy provisions, or failing to explain the reasons for a claim denial within a specific time period. As a serious offense, insurance fraud can result in severe legal consequences, including criminal charges, fines, and even imprisonment.

Elements of Insurance Fraud

Insurance fraud occurs when someone intentionally deceives an insurance company for financial gain. Here are some key elements to be aware of:

  • Misrepresentation of Facts: Deliberately providing false information to an insurance company about coverage or policy provisions, intending to deceive the insurer.
  • False Claims: Submitting a claim to an insurance company with false information or fabricated incidents to obtain undeserved reimbursement or benefits.
  • Staged Accidents: Orchestrating an accident or damage to a property to claim insurance benefits from the occurrence.
  • Forgery: Using fake or altered documents to support an insurance claim or to obtain an insurance policy.
  • Concealing Information: Deliberately withholding relevant information from the insurance company, to influence coverage or claim decisions.
  • Agents and Brokers Fraud: Insurance agents or brokers participating in fraudulent activities such as pocketing clients’ premiums or selling false policies.
  • Post-dated Coverage: Trying to obtain insurance coverage for an incident that has already occurred, and falsely representing the incident as occurring after the policy’s inception.

If you suspect insurance fraud, contact your insurance company or local authorities to report the potential crime. Be cautious of potential scams and always verify information before making decisions involving insurance coverage or claims.

Identifying Attempted Insurance Fraud

  • False Statements or Claims: One sign of attempted insurance fraud is when an individual knowingly makes false or misleading statements to deceive an insurance company, with the intention of collecting money they aren’t entitled to.
  • Exaggerated Damages: In cases of car or property insurance claims, a person may exaggerate the extent of damages sustained to get a higher reimbursement from the insurance company.
  • Fake Injuries: Attempted insurance fraud can occur when someone pretends to have an injury to obtain payments or prescription medication from a health insurance provider.
  • Healthcare Provider Fraud: This type of fraud happens when healthcare providers such as doctors or dentists submit false claims for procedures they didn’t perform.
  • Unreported Changes: A person could attempt insurance fraud by not reporting changes in circumstances that would affect their insurance coverage or premiums.

Identifying attempted insurance fraud is essential to protect both consumers and insurance companies from higher premiums and unnecessary expenses. Be aware of these signs and report any suspicious activities to your insurer or the relevant fraud bureaus.

Legal Consequences of Attempted Insurance Fraud

  • Criminal Charges: Attempted insurance fraud is a crime in all fifty states, and individuals caught trying to deceive insurance companies can face criminal charges, including potential misdemeanor or felony charges depending on the severity of the fraud.
  • Fines and Restitution: Courts can impose hefty fines on those convicted of attempted insurance fraud. Additionally, they may also require the defendant to pay restitution to the insurance company for any damages or expenses incurred due to the fraudulent attempt.
  • Imprisonment: Depending on the nature and extent of the attempted fraud, individuals found guilty can face imprisonment, with sentences ranging from a few months to several years.
  • Civil Lawsuits: Insurance companies can also sue individuals for attempted insurance fraud, which can result in the defendant being ordered to pay monetary damages to the insurer.
  • Increased Premiums: Insurance fraud affects everyone, as insurance companies charge higher premiums to cover their losses from fraud. When attempting insurance fraud is discovered, it may result in higher premiums for the individual in the future.
  • Loss of Coverage: Insurance companies may choose to cancel the coverage of those found attempting to commit insurance fraud, leaving them without insurance and potentially facing difficulties in obtaining future coverage.
  • Damage to Reputation: A conviction for attempted insurance fraud can have lasting effects on an individual’s reputation, possibly making it difficult to secure employment, loans, or other forms of financial assistance.
  • License Suspension: In some cases, professionals, such as doctors or dentists, found guilty of attempted insurance fraud can have their professional licenses suspended or revoked, resulting in the loss of their practice.
  • Criminal Record: A conviction for attempted insurance fraud will result in a permanent criminal record, which may have long-term consequences, such as limiting employment opportunities and affecting eligibility for certain benefits.
  • Future Legal Consequences: A previous conviction for attempted insurance fraud can have an impact on future legal proceedings, potentially leading to harsher sentences if the individual is found guilty of further crimes.

Can You Sue Someone for Attempted Insurance Fraud?

Yes, you can sue someone for attempting insurance fraud. Insurance fraud is a serious crime and can take several forms, including misrepresentation of facts, policy provisions, or deliberately causing an accident to collect insurance money. If you believe you have been a victim of insurance fraud, it is essential to seek legal counsel and gather solid evidence to build a strong case against the perpetrator.

In situations like false car accident claims, it is necessary to understand the difference between hard fraud and soft fraud. Hard fraud involves intentionally causing or staging an accident, while soft fraud refers to exaggerating damages or injuries to receive a higher insurance payout. To protect yourself against false claims, always call 911 and obtain an official accident report, keeping track of all relevant information and evidence. Having a legal professional specializing in insurance fraud cases will assist you in navigating the legal process and ensuring your rights are protected. [9][10]

Civil Lawsuit Process for Attempted Insurance Fraud

  • Identifying Insurance Fraud: The first stage is to identify and gather evidence of the alleged attempted insurance fraud. This may involve misrepresentations, false statements, or concealments by the defendant.
  • Consultation with Legal Expert: To establish a strong case, consult with a law firm experienced in handling insurance fraud lawsuits, such as the Sterling Firm or John D. Kirby Law Offices.
  • Filing a Civil Complaint: Fraud claims must be filed with particularity, demonstrating specific facts and elements according to state laws. Details including who, what, where, when, and how will be required.
  • Notification & Discovery: The defendant will be served with the complaint and will have an opportunity to respond. The evidence will be exchanged between parties through discovery.
  • Litigation & Negotiations: The plaintiff and defendant will present their respective cases to the court. Settlement negotiations may also occur at this stage to avoid a lengthy legal battle.
  • Civil Trial: If negotiations are unsuccessful or parties choose to proceed to trial, both parties will present their cases to a jury, who will decide liability and assess damages if necessary.
  • Compensation & Rectification: If the plaintiff is successful, the court may award monetary compensation for damages suffered as a result of the attempted insurance fraud.

Factors Influencing the Outcome of a Lawsuit for Attempted Insurance Fraud

  • Intent to defraud: A prosecutor must prove that the person involved knowingly committed an act to defraud, as insurance fraud is a specific intent crime.
  • Completed act: The suspect must have made a misrepresentation (written or oral) to an insurer with full knowledge that it was false information.
  • Proof of the misconduct: The claimant must provide evidence supporting the occurrence of insurance fraud, such as documentation, witness testimonies, and expert opinions.
  • Timely reporting: The claim must be reported within the specified statute of limitations for insurance fraud lawsuits.
  • Legal representation: Effective legal representation, particularly from lawyers experienced in handling insurance fraud cases, is vital for a successful outcome.
  • Insurance company’s response: The insurer’s actions, such as timely claim denial and furnishing proper explanations, can impact the lawsuit outcome.
  • Existing regulations: Compliance with license requirements, pre-licensing, and continuing education can influence the lawsuit results.
  • Cooperation of involved entities: A collaborative investigation led by insurance companies, agents, and law enforcement can help uncover attempted insurance fraud and strengthen the lawsuit.

Statute of Limitations for Filing a Lawsuit

  • Understanding the Statute of Limitations: The statute of limitations is a law that sets a specific time frame within which you must file a lawsuit. It varies depending on the type of case and jurisdiction.
  • Importance of Timeliness: Failing to file a lawsuit within the specified time limit will lead to dismissal of the case, regardless of its merits.
  • Insurance Fraud Cases: In most U.S states, insurance fraud can be charged as a misdemeanor or felony, with a five-year statute of limitations for federal offenses.
  • Extension in Certain Cases: In some situations, the statute of limitations can be extended to six years, such as in New Jersey.
  • Defending Against Charges: If charged with insurance fraud, a criminal defense attorney can help establish the best possible defense based on your case’s specifics.
  • Consequences of Delay: Missing the deadline for filing a lawsuit can result in hefty fines, incarceration, or the case being dismissed early.
  • Expert Assistance: Consulting with an experienced attorney can help ensure that crucial evidence is collected and a strong defense is created for your case.


In conclusion, insurance fraud is a serious offense that can result in significant financial losses, impacting both consumers and insurance companies alike. It is important for individuals to be aware of their rights and the legal recourse available to them if they suspect they have fallen victim to fraudulent practices. As demonstrated by the data, insurance fraud comes in various forms, and efforts must be made to combat this issue on all fronts. While it may not always be possible to sue someone for attempted insurance fraud, seeking legal advice from experienced professionals like the Law Offices of John D. Kirby in San Diego is an essential step in pursuing justice.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *